Hamas’s Claim on Hostage Release Refuted by Israel

In a recent development, Hamas alleges that Israel declined the release of two hostages, while Israel labels the claim as deceptive propaganda.

Quick Facts

  • Hamas’s Assault: On October 7, Hamas captured approximately 210 individuals in southern Israel, who are now detained in undisclosed locations within Gaza.
  • Hostage Release Offer: Hamas claims to have proposed the release of two Israelis without expecting any reciprocation, which Israel reportedly rejected.
  • Mediation by Qatar: Qatar, having played a role in the release of two Americans, has not commented on the recent claims by Hamas.

The situation unfolded when Hamas’s armed wing, the al-Qassam Brigades, announced their intention to release two Israelis, Nourit Yitshaq and Yokhefed Lifshitz, for humanitarian reasons. This was communicated to the mediator, Qatar, which had previously facilitated the release of two Americans, Judith Tai Ranaan and her daughter Natalie. However, Israel’s response was to dismiss the claim as “mendacious propaganda”.

Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu’s office issued a brief statement emphasizing their commitment to bringing back all kidnapped and missing individuals. They refrained from engaging with what they termed as “false propaganda by Hamas”. Meanwhile, Hamas remains steadfast in its claim, with spokesperson Khaled al-Qaddoumi expressing disappointment at Israel’s alleged refusal, emphasizing that their intention was purely humanitarian.

Further insights into the situation were provided by Akiva Eldar, an Israeli political analyst. He suggested that if Hamas genuinely intends to release the hostages, they could coordinate with organizations like the International Committee of the Red Cross or even allow the hostages to cross into Egypt. This perspective underscores the complexities of the situation, especially considering the broader context of the Israel-Gaza conflict.

For Further Reading Qatar’s Mediation Role: Qatar has been actively involved in mediating between conflicting parties in the Middle East. In this context, they played a pivotal role in the release of two American hostages held by Hamas. Qatar’s diplomatic efforts often aim at de-escalating tensions and facilitating dialogue. Their involvement in the Israel-Gaza situation is a testament to their commitment to regional peace. [Wikipedia Source]


Q: Who are the two Israelis that Hamas claims to have offered for release?

A: The two Israelis are Nourit Yitshaq and Yokhefed Lifshitz.

Q: How did Israel respond to Hamas’s claim?

A: Israel labeled the claim as “mendacious propaganda” and did not engage further with the assertion.

Q: What role did Qatar play in the recent developments?

A: Qatar acted as a mediator and was informed of Hamas’s intention to release the two Israelis. They had previously facilitated the release of two Americans held by Hamas.

Source: Al Jazeera

Leave a Comment