A two-court push to wipe out a historic felony verdict
New York, NY — November 17, 2026.
Donald Trump’s legal team is pressing an aggressive two-front campaign in New York’s state and federal appellate courts to erase his May 2024 criminal conviction on 34 felony counts of falsifying business records.
On Monday, November 16, a three-judge panel of the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit heard more than an hour of oral arguments on Trump’s bid to transfer the completed state prosecution into the federal court system, according to the Chicago Tribune and courthouse reporting.
The federal hearing came just 11 days after Trump’s lawyers asked a five-judge New York state appellate panel to throw out the same verdict directly, underscoring the president’s effort to clear the first felony conviction of an American president through whichever judicial door opens first.
Inside the Second Circuit removal showdown
At the federal courthouse in Lower Manhattan, defense attorney Robert J. Giuffra Jr. urged the Second Circuit panel—which included Circuit Judge Raymond Lohier—to overturn earlier removal denials by the late U.S. District Judge Alvin Hellerstein and shift the case out of state court.
In plain English, “federal removal” allows a federal official to move certain state prosecutions into federal court when the charges stem from official federal duties. Giuffra argued the defense is entitled to that transfer so federal judges can revisit the jury’s verdict under the U.S. Supreme Court’s 2024 presidential immunity ruling, Trump v. United States, contending that trial prosecutors relied on evidence tied to official acts such as Oval Office conversations and social media posts. He also asked the Second Circuit for an expedited order pausing state appellate deliberations while the federal question is resolved.
Representing the Manhattan District Attorney’s Office, appeals division chief Steven Wu urged the federal panel to leave the case in New York state court. Wu argued that Trump’s removal bid was untimely and that the underlying conduct—reimbursing hush money payments tied to adult film actress Stormy Daniels ahead of the 2016 election—involved private, unofficial acts that state appellate courts are fully equipped to review.
The parallel state appeal and what comes next
Before Monday’s federal hearing, Giuffra and Manhattan prosecutors argued on November 5 before a five-judge panel of New York’s Appellate Division, First Department. In that direct state appeal, Trump’s attorneys challenged the trial court’s jury instructions, the admission of presidential-term evidence, and prosecutors’ use of a federal election-law theory to elevate state misdemeanor falsification charges into felonies.
District Attorney Alvin Bragg’s office has defended the trial record in both forums, maintaining that federal campaign law was only one of multiple unlawful means cited to conceal the reimbursement scheme and that personal cover-ups do not trigger presidential immunity.
During Monday’s Second Circuit argument, judges pressed Trump’s attorneys on the unusual procedural posture of trying to move a case to federal court after a state jury verdict and sentencing have already occurred. Neither the Second Circuit panel nor the New York Appellate Division issued an immediate ruling, leaving the timing and outcome of both appeals open.