Latest
Hollywood

Sarah Paulson Explains Why She and Holland Taylor Won't Marry: 'The Stoneness of It Gives Me the Heebie-Jeebies'

Appearing on Chelsea Handler's podcast, the Emmy-winning actress opened up about maintaining independence and defying traditional marital labels in her decade-long romance with Holland Taylor.

Read the story
Hollywood · Read the story
Newstro Hollywood section banner.
Newstro
Share this story

Emmy-winning star talks independence, domestic freedom, and why legally binding vows don't fit their decadelong bond

Los Angeles, California — November 13, 2026, 3:30 a.m. EST.

After more than ten years of public romance that has charmed Hollywood and rewritten red-carpet conventions, Sarah Paulson has delivered a refreshingly frank, unsentimental answer to why she and longtime partner Holland Taylor will never walk down the aisle: the sheer permanence of a legal marriage contract gives her "the heebie-jeebies."

Speaking candidly on comedian Chelsea Handler’s Dear Chelsea podcast, the 49-year-old American Crime Story and American Horror Story star dismantled standard expectations around long-term domestic partnerships. While stressing that she and the 83-year-old Emmy winner are completely intertwined and emotionally devoted, Paulson revealed that the rigid institutional framing of matrimony triggers an instinctive desire to preserve personal sovereignty.

"The stoneness of it makes me want to, like, it gives me the heebie-jeebies," Paulson told Handler during the in-depth interview. "I want to feel this kind of freedom. That's not about being away from her or being with another person. It's just about maintaining some sense of my own independence, and I think Holland feels that way too."

Rejecting 'wife' labels and domestic stereotypes

Beyond the legal framework of marriage, Paulson shared that both she and Taylor actively dislike conventional domestic labels, particularly the term "wife." The actress explained that the traditional connotations of the title feel misaligned with who she is as an autonomous artist and partner.

"I think there's something about the word 'wife' that makes me feel like I have to put on an apron and bake a pie," Paulson said with a laugh. "It's just not who I am. We've built something that works for us, on our own terms, without needing society's pre-packaged script of what a relationship should look like."

The couple, who first met at a dinner party in 2005 before connecting on social media and dating in 2015, have long lived in separate nearby homes in Los Angeles. Paulson has previously credited having their own spaces with helping their relationship thrive, allowing each partner to read, work, and recharge without compromising individual habits.

A decadelong romance built on honesty and mutual respect

Throughout their decadelong relationship, Paulson and Taylor have been celebrated for their affectionate, unapologetic public presence, often addressing inquiries about their 32-year age difference with humor and perspective. Taylor, best known for her acclaimed roles in The Practice, Legally Blonde, and Two and a Half Men, has echoed Paulson’s philosophy in past interviews, calling their connection "the most wonderful, extraordinary thing that could have ever happened in my life."

Paulson emphasized that avoiding marriage is not an indication of fragility or hesitation, but rather a deliberate choice to choose each other daily without a legal tether holding them in place.

"When you don't have a legally binding contract keeping you in a room together, waking up every single morning and choosing to stay feels that much more meaningful," Paulson reflected. "We have the commitment without the paperwork."

Timeline of Sarah Paulson and Holland Taylor’s relationship

2005: Sarah Paulson and Holland Taylor first meet while attending an industry dinner party hosted by playwright Donald Margulies.

Early 2015: The pair cross paths again while collaborating on a Martha Graham Dance Company public service video and begin direct-messaging on Twitter/X.

December 2015: Taylor reveals in a radio interview that she is in a deeply committed relationship with a younger woman; Paulson confirms their romance shortly thereafter.

September 2016: Paulson wins the Primetime Emmy Award for her portrayal of Marcia Clark and declares from the podium: "Holland Taylor, I love you."

2020–2024: The couple maintains separate Los Angeles residences, frequently citing personal space as the key to long-term harmony.

November 11, 2026: On Chelsea Handler's Dear Chelsea podcast, Paulson confirms they will never marry, explaining that the legal permanence gives her "the heebie-jeebies."