Midnight collision on Broadway leads to misdemeanor surrender
Nashville, Tenn. — November 14, 2026 · 4:25 a.m. CST.
Former NFL head coach and current ESPN studio analyst Rex Ryan turned himself in to police in Tennessee this week after being formally charged on six misdemeanor criminal counts arising from an alleged late-night hit-and-run involving pedestrians in downtown Nashville.
According to charging documents released by the Metropolitan Nashville Police Department (MNPD), the 63-year-old former coach of the New York Jets and Buffalo Bills surrendered to authorities on Wednesday morning at the downtown booking facility. Police issued six arrest warrants following an investigation into an incident that occurred shortly before midnight on November 5 at the bustling intersection of 4th Avenue North and Broadway, the heart of Nashville’s famed entertainment strip.
Affidavits filed in Davidson County General Sessions Court state that attorney Michael Holland and his wife were legally crossing Broadway inside the marked crosswalk with an active pedestrian walk signal when a full-size pickup truck registered to Ryan made an abrupt right turn off 4th Avenue, striking both pedestrians and driving over their feet.
Couple recounts near-miss encounter and confrontation at red light
In public statements, Holland detailed the terrifying sequence of events, stating that only quick reflexes saved them from catastrophic injury. "If we had been six inches further out into the lane, I'd be in a hospital right now, and so would my wife," Holland told reporters. "He ran directly over my foot and clipped my wife's leg."
According to police reports, the truck did not immediately stop after striking the couple. Instead, the vehicle continued down Broadway before getting caught in traffic at a red light near Representative John Lewis Way, approximately one block away.
The couple pursued the truck on foot and flagged down the driver. When Ryan opened the door and stepped out onto the street, an intense verbal argument erupted. Witnesses and victims stated that Ryan refused to provide insurance information or check on their physical condition, instead shouting at the couple before climbing back into the pickup truck and speeding away as the light turned green. Holland managed to take multiple clear photographs of the driver, the vehicle, and its license plate on his smartphone, which were immediately turned over to investigating traffic officers.
Six counts filed as ESPN analyst qualifies for pretrial release
Following a review of witness statements, street surveillance video, and registration databases, Nashville police obtained warrants charging Ryan with two counts of leaving the scene of an accident involving injury, two counts of failure to render aid and provide information, and two counts of failure to obey a traffic control signal.
A judicial commissioner set Ryan's bond at $6,000, and he was processed and released under pretrial supervision conditions. A formal court appearance has been scheduled for December 18, 2026, before Davidson County Judge Rachel Bell.
Ryan, who led the New York Jets to back-to-back AFC Championship appearances in 2009 and 2010 before coaching the Buffalo Bills, has been a prominent fixture on ESPN’s NFL Sunday Countdown and other studio programming. Neither Ryan nor his legal representatives have released an on-the-record defense, and network executives have not commented on his broadcast schedule heading into the weekend slate of games.