Internal records uncover tragic failures on Cincinnati school bus
November 15, 2026 · 12:40 a.m. Central
Devastating internal communications released under Ohio public records law have revealed that private school bus contractor First Student admitted hours after the tragic death of 7-year-old disabled student Ngone Talla that its onboard personnel failed to properly strap the child into her wheelchair harness, directly causing her fatal suffocation.
Ngone Talla, a nonverbal second-grader with developmental disabilities who attended Roselawn Condon School in Cincinnati, died while being transported home on a district-contracted First Student bus in September. While early public statements from district officials described the incident as a sudden and unexplained medical emergency, newly uncovered emails obtained by The Cincinnati Enquirer prove that top administrators knew that same evening that the child's restraint had failed.
According to the newly released documents, Cincinnati Public Schools Superintendent Shauna Murphy sent an urgent email to school board members at 8:39 p.m. on the night of Ngone's death, writing that John Kenning, the president and chief executive officer of First Student, had personally phoned her with an alarming admission: the driver and bus monitor had failed to fasten the child's harness appropriately, resulting in her death.
