Latest
In The News

Ohio Judge Dismisses Rep. Max Miller’s Defamation Lawsuit Against Ex-Wife, Calling Abuse Claim ‘Substantially True’

Cuyahoga County Common Pleas Judge Joy Kennedy threw out the outgoing GOP congressman's suit with prejudice under Ohio's anti-SLAPP law and ordered over $75,000 in attorney fees.

Read the story
In The News · Read the story
Newstro In The News section banner.
Newstro
Share this story

Judge throws out suit with prejudice under Ohio anti-SLAPP law

An Ohio judge on Monday dismissed outgoing U.S. Rep. Max Miller’s defamation and false-light lawsuit against his ex-wife, Emily Moreno, concluding that a central domestic abuse allegation at the heart of the case was “substantially true,” according to The Washington Post and The Daily Beast.

In a 16-page decision, Cuyahoga County Court of Common Pleas Judge Joy Kennedy granted Moreno’s motion for expedited relief under Ohio’s Uniform Public Expression Protection Act (UPEPA)—the state’s anti-SLAPP statute enacted in 2025—dismissing Miller’s complaint with prejudice so it cannot be refiled in the same court.

Miller, an Ohio Republican who lost his reelection bid in the 7th Congressional District on November 3 to Democrat Brian Poindexter, had sued Moreno in May 2026 over a Daily Mail report detailing allegations from their 2025 divorce and custody dispute that he had doused her with hot water during an argument in 2024.

What the ruling found on the hot-water allegation and media leaks

Judge Kennedy wrote that even when viewing the record in the light most favorable to Miller, “there is no credible evidence in support of Plaintiff’s claims against Defendant Moreno,” Radar Online and Raw Story reported alongside court filings published by Moreno’s counsel.

The court found Miller failed to prove Moreno leaked information to the press or acted with actual malice. Addressing the underlying incident, Judge Kennedy pointed to prior court and police records, injury photographs, and an audio recording in which Miller acknowledged pouring hot water on Moreno—while contending he lacked intent to harm—concluding he “has not shown that the statement about dousing Defendant Moreno with boiling hot water are false” and that “[t]he imputation that Plaintiff poured or doused Defendant Moreno with hot water is substantially true.”

$75,000 fee order and planned appeal

Under UPEPA’s mandatory fee-shifting provision, Judge Kennedy ordered Miller to pay court costs and more than $75,000 of Moreno’s attorney fees and legal expenses.

Miller’s lawyer, Aaron Minc, disputed the outcome and said Miller intends to challenge it in appellate court. “The lawsuit was entirely warranted and was brought based on egregious facts and defamatory statements,” Minc said in an email to reporters, adding that Miller’s legal team expects the dismissal to be overturned on appeal.

What comes next is whether an Ohio appeals court accepts Miller’s challenge to the anti-SLAPP dismissal and fee award after his congressional term concludes in January.

Cuyahoga County Court of Common Pleas in Cleveland

The civil ruling was issued Monday in Cuyahoga County Court of Common Pleas in downtown Cleveland, Ohio.

★ Downtown Cleveland, Ohio — Cuyahoga County Court of Common Pleas district. Map data: OpenStreetMap contributors.

Litigation timeline

  1. — Alleged hot-water argument occurs during the marriage of Max Miller and Emily Moreno, later documented in custody and divorce proceedings completed in 2025.
  2. — Following a Daily Mail article reporting the allegation, Miller files a defamation and false-light lawsuit against Moreno in Cuyahoga County Court of Common Pleas.
  3. — Democrat Brian Poindexter defeats Miller (54.9% to 45.1%) in Ohio’s 7th Congressional District general election.
  4. — Judge Joy Kennedy dismisses Miller’s lawsuit with prejudice under Ohio’s UPEPA anti-SLAPP law and orders over $75,000 in attorney fees; Miller’s counsel vows to appeal.

Sources and reporting credits

Sources: The Washington Post, The Daily Beast, Radar Online, Raw Story.

Visuals: Newstro.