House lawmakers confront acting Navy Secretary Hung Cao over unannounced command reliefs following underwater seabed strike
Washington, D.C. — November 13, 2026, 3:30 a.m. EST.
Senior leaders on the House Armed Services Committee have delivered a stinging rebuke to Pentagon leadership, accusing the U.S. Navy of an unprecedented breakdown in institutional transparency after military officials quietly ousted multiple high-profile commanding officers—including the entire leadership team of a nuclear attack submarine involved in an undersea collision—without notifying Congress or the public.
In a sharply worded letter addressed to acting Navy Secretary Hung Cao and Chief of Naval Operations Adm. Daryl Caudle, House Armed Services Committee Ranking Member Adam Smith (D-WA) and Seapower Subcommittee Ranking Member Joe Courtney (D-CT) demanded an immediate accounting of several unannounced command reliefs executed over the past two months. The lawmakers warned that abandoning the military's decades-long precedent of publicly announcing commanding officer firings threatens civilian oversight and erodes trust between Capitol Hill and the sea service.
"The Navy's longstanding policy of publicly announcing the relief of commanding officers exists for a reason: accountability, deterrence, and maintaining the highest standards of command," Smith and Courtney wrote. "Handling major command dismissals in secrecy—only to have Congress learn about them through press inquiries weeks later—undermines the constitutional oversight responsibilities of this committee."
USS South Dakota seabed strike kept under wraps for weeks
At the center of congressional fury is the unpublicized removal of the top three officers aboard the USS South Dakota (SSN-790), a fast-attack Virginia-class nuclear submarine. On October 14, 2026, Navy leadership relieved the commanding officer, executive officer, and chief of the boat—the entire command triad—following an undisclosed incident in which the multi-billion-dollar vessel made contact with the seabed during operations.
While the Navy routinely issues formal public notices citing "loss of confidence in ability to command" when warship skippers are removed, no announcement was made regarding the USS South Dakota. Congressional defense committees were never briefed, discovering the reliefs only after defense journalists pressed naval officials for comment nearly a month after the fact.
The letter also revealed that the commanding officer of a guided-missile destroyer deployed to the Middle East was quietly relieved of duty in September 2026 with no public acknowledgment, as well as the unannounced departure of Rear Adm. Dr. Brian P. Monahan, who had served for years as the Attending Physician to the United States Congress and the Supreme Court amid an internal Navy inquiry.
Political stakes rise ahead of Senate confirmation hearings
The controversy erupts at a delicate moment for the Department of the Navy. Acting Secretary Hung Cao, nominated to the top civilian post by the White House following post-midterm executive reshuffling, is currently preparing for formal Senate confirmation hearings before the Armed Services Committee.
Congressional aides indicated that lawmakers intend to press Cao directly on whether the quiet firings reflect a deliberate policy shift toward tighter information control. Navy spokespersons defended the handling of the cases, maintaining that command decisions are evaluated individually with respect to operational security and personnel privacy, but conceded that leadership is reviewing Congressional notification procedures.
"Transparency is not an administrative courtesy; it is essential to naval readiness and safety," Courtney stressed in an interview. "When a nuclear submarine strikes the ocean floor or a forward-deployed warship loses its skipper, the American public and the Congress must know that the Navy is taking accountable, verifiable action."
Timeline of the Navy's undisclosed command reliefs and congressional response
September 2026: The commanding officer of a U.S. guided-missile destroyer operating in the Middle East is quietly dismissed without public release.
October 14, 2026: The entire command triad of the Virginia-class nuclear submarine USS South Dakota (SSN-790) is relieved following an undersea seabed collision.
Late October 2026: Rear Adm. Brian P. Monahan departs his post as Attending Physician to Congress and the Supreme Court amid an internal service probe.
November 10, 2026: Media inquiries force the Navy to confirm the USS South Dakota dismissals after nearly a month of public silence.
November 12, 2026: Rep. Adam Smith and Rep. Joe Courtney send a formal oversight letter to acting Navy Secretary Hung Cao and CNO Adm. Daryl Caudle demanding full transparency.