Judge William Sullivan schedules second trial for March 2027 following hung jury deadlock
Plymouth, Massachusetts — November 16, 2026 · 11:45 a.m. EST
Lindsay Clancy will stand trial a second time on three counts of first-degree murder beginning March 29, 2027, for the 2023 strangulation deaths of her three young children, after Plymouth Superior Court Judge William Sullivan rejected defense efforts to throw out the case on double-jeopardy grounds, as reported by CBS News Boston, BBC News, and the New York Post.
During a consequential status hearing on Monday morning in Plymouth, Judge Sullivan formally set the trial date, rebuffing a prosecution proposal to delay proceedings until May and declaring that "the die has been cast." Sullivan noted that his impending mandatory judicial retirement in June 2027 required setting an immovable spring trial window to ensure the case reaches a definitive verdict under his supervision.
Clancy, 34, a former Massachusetts General Hospital labor and delivery nurse, is charged with strangling her five-year-old daughter Cora, three-year-old son Dawson, and eight-month-old infant Callan inside their suburban Duxbury home on January 24, 2023, before attempting suicide by leaping from a second-story window. The fall left Clancy permanently paralyzed from the waist down.
Defense double-jeopardy challenge denied after 11–1 deadlock in high-stakes first trial
The scheduling follows the abrupt conclusion of Clancy's seven-week initial trial on September 4, 2026, which ended in a mistrial when jurors declared themselves hopelessly deadlocked after four days of deliberations. Subsequent disclosures revealed that the jury had split 11–1 in favor of acquitting Clancy by reason of lack of criminal responsibility due to severe mental illness.
Defense attorney Kevin Reddington filed post-trial motions asserting that forcing Clancy to endure a second trial constituted unconstitutional double jeopardy, arguing that the Commonwealth had failed to present sufficient evidence of sanity beyond a reasonable doubt. Prosecutors from the Plymouth County District Attorney's Office vehemently opposed the motion, arguing that longstanding Massachusetts precedent firmly establishes that a genuine jury deadlock does not terminate jeopardy or preclude retrial.
In a written memorandum released alongside Monday's hearing, Judge Sullivan denied the defense motions, affirming that the state retains the constitutional prerogative to retry unresolved felony indictments when a jury cannot achieve unanimity.
Clashing psychiatric portraits: Postpartum psychosis against alleged premeditation
The upcoming retrial will once again center on the volatile intersection of maternal psychiatric crisis and criminal responsibility. Throughout the first trial, the defense marshaled testimony from leading reproductive psychiatrists and toxicologists who testified that Clancy was suffering from acute postpartum psychosis compounded by involuntary intoxication from a cocktail of 13 psychiatric medications prescribed in the months before the tragedy.
Medical records introduced into evidence documented that Clancy had repeatedly sought professional treatment for intrusive thoughts, hallucinations, and devastating depression, checking herself into McLean Hospital just weeks prior to the killings. Defense experts maintained that an auditory hallucination commanded her to harm the children to save them from perceived damnation.
Conversely, prosecutors contended that Clancy acted with calculated deliberation and extreme atrocity or cruelty. They emphasized that she dispatched her husband, Patrick Clancy, on an errand to pick up takeout medicine and food, utilized exercise bands to strangle each child in separate rooms, and researched the timing of the errands on her mobile phone. While prosecutors expressed a preference for a late-spring trial to accommodate expert witness schedules, Sullivan ordered both sides to be trial-ready by March 29.