Landmark privacy penalty in Rome
November 14, 2026 · 2:05 p.m. Central
Italy’s data protection authority, the Garante per la protezione dei dati personali, has hit social media giant Meta with a historic €805 million ($887 million USD) fine following an extensive investigation into how the Facebook application for Android devices accessed users' personal photo and video rolls.
The penalty centers on a mobile feature introduced in 2023 titled "Get suggestions from your gallery while browsing Facebook." The regulator determined that the feature routinely examined photos, videos, and device metadata residing on users' smartphones without securing specific, unbundled, and freely given consent, as reported by BBC News.
Officials estimated that approximately 20 million Android users in Italy were impacted by the automated photo scanning mechanism. The Italian privacy watchdog rejected Meta's procedural defense that the inquiry belonged exclusively in Ireland under the European Union’s General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR) one-stop-shop framework, holding that local device access falls strictly under national ePrivacy statutes.
How gallery suggestions bypassed explicit consent
According to findings published by the Garante, the Facebook application sought access to users’ media libraries through a single, broad authorization prompt presented under the guise of general feature enablement. Once authorized, the gallery suggestion functionality was turned on by default, silently indexing camera roll contents to surface suggested status posts and reels while users scrolled through their feeds.
The regulator concluded that this bundled approach prevented users from understanding that granting permission for basic app functions also activated background scanning of their private personal photos. In its formal decision, the authority underscored that smartphones represent an intimate sphere of personal life, where access to stored files demands granular transparency.
The investigation originally began in July 2025 following a formal consumer alert lodged by the Consumer Protection Center of Bolzano (Centro Tutela Consumatori Utenti), prompting technical audits of Facebook’s Android software packages, as detailed in coverage by The Next Web and CNBC.
60-day compliance order and legal showdown
In addition to the €805 million financial sanction, the Italian authority ordered Meta Platforms Ireland Limited to overhaul its mobile interface within 60 calendar days. Meta must disable gallery suggestions by default across all active installations in Italy and require separate, unambiguous opt-in consent before examining local media files, even from users who had previously tapped approval prompts.
Meta argued during the proceedings that the feature processed media locally on the device to create helpful posting prompts and asserted that cross-border EU inquiries must be coordinated through Ireland's Data Protection Commission. However, the Italian watchdog firmly held that Article 122 of the Italian Privacy Code—which implements Article 5(3) of the European ePrivacy Directive—gives national authorities sovereign power over device terminal integrity.
A spokesperson for Meta stated that the company strongly disagrees with the decision, maintaining that users were given clear notices and controls, and confirmed intentions to file an appeal before the civil courts in Rome. The legal challenge sets up another major battleground between Silicon Valley tech giants and European privacy watchdogs over mobile operating system permissions.