Latest
Election

DOJ Widens ‘Other Dan Sullivan’ Criminal Probe With Over 200 Subpoenas After Peltola Win

Federal prosecutors have issued more than 200 subpoenas across multiple states in an expanding investigation into the recruitment of independent candidate Daniel J. Sullivan Jr., even after Democrat Mary Peltola won Alaska’s U.S. Senate race.

Read the story
Election · Read the story
Newstro Election section banner.
Newstro
Share this story

Hundreds of subpoenas issued despite Peltola victory

Juneau, Alaska — November 19, 2026 · 08:12 a.m. CST (14:12 UTC).

The U.S. Department of Justice is expanding its criminal investigation into the appearance of a second candidate named Dan Sullivan on Alaska’s U.S. Senate ballot, issuing more than 200 subpoenas across multiple states even after Democrat Mary Peltola was declared the winner of the race, according to Newsweek and Fox News.

Peltola defeated Republican incumbent Sen. Dan S. Sullivan in Alaska’s tight four-way ranked-choice contest on November 18, flipping the seat for Democrats, as Global News reported. Yet federal officials told reporters that the election outcome has not slowed the grand jury probe examining whether political operatives illegally coordinated to place a namesake spoiler on the ballot.

"Peltola’s win doesn’t change anything with the ongoing criminal investigation," a law enforcement source told Yahoo.

How the ‘Other Dan Sullivan’ landed on the ballot

The inquiry focuses on Daniel J. Sullivan Jr., a retired schoolteacher from Petersburg, Alaska, who ran as an independent alongside the Republican incumbent of the same name. Following pre-election reporting by The New York Times describing a "ballot composition project," federal prosecutors began investigating whether Democratic campaign aides, outside operatives, or national party strategists recruited the second Dan Sullivan to confuse voters and siphon support from the incumbent.

According to the Daily Mail, investigators have also served records requests and target letters in connection with the multi-state sweep, including to prominent Democratic election lawyer Marc Elias, whose firm represented Peltola’s campaign.

Campaign denials and certification fight

Peltola and her campaign have denied any knowledge of or involvement in recruiting the independent candidate, while Elias and his firm have condemned the Justice Department’s inquiry as a politically motivated "sham." Under federal law, running as a candidate with the same name as an opponent is not automatically a crime, meaning prosecutors would have to prove underlying fraud, false statements, or illegal campaign coordination.

Separately from the criminal grand jury probe, Republicans have pursued civil legal challenges seeking to scrutinize voter confusion ahead of final certification. No criminal indictments have been announced as of Thursday morning.

Juneau, Alaska — State Election Administration

Alaska’s Division of Elections oversees statewide ranked-choice tabulations and certification from Juneau, while independent candidate Daniel J. Sullivan Jr. hails from Petersburg in Southeast Alaska.

★ Broad Juneau, Alaska area, seat of state government and election administration. Map data: OpenStreetMap contributors, ODbL. Open map.

Timeline of the Alaska Senate probe

  1. — Alaska voters cast ballots in a four-way U.S. Senate race featuring both Republican Sen. Dan S. Sullivan and independent Daniel J. Sullivan Jr.
  2. — Following media disclosures of a "ballot composition project," the Justice Department opens a criminal investigation and sends a target letter to Democratic attorney Marc Elias.
  3. — Ranked-choice tabulations project Democrat Mary Peltola as the winner; federal officials confirm more than 200 subpoenas have been issued and the probe remains active.

Sources and reporting credits

Sources: Newsweek, Fox News, Daily Mail, Yahoo, and Global News.

Visuals: Newstro.