Advocates mount constitutional challenge arguing U.S. immigration enforcement violates Charter equality protections
Toronto, Canada — November 13, 2026, 7:15 a.m. EST.
A formidable coalition of human rights organizations and refugee advocates returned to the Federal Court of Canada this week, launching a high-stakes constitutional lawsuit challenging the federal government's policy of turning back asylum seekers to the United States under the Safe Third Country Agreement (STCA).
Led by Amnesty International Canada, the Canadian Council for Refugees (CCR), and the Canadian Council of Churches, alongside eight individual refugee claimants, the legal action contends that aggressive mass deportations, expanded Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) roundups, and punitive detention policies under President Donald Trump have made the United States fundamentally unsafe for vulnerable people seeking sanctuary.
"The premise of the Safe Third Country Agreement has always been that the United States offers a fair, humane, and protective alternative asylum system," Gauri Sreenivasan, co-executive director of the Canadian Council for Refugees, told reporters outside the Toronto courthouse. "That premise has completely dissolved. Sending desperate individuals directly into the hands of an militarized ICE apparatus that detains them indefinitely and strips away due process is an abdication of Canada's legal and moral duties."
Our challenge against the Safe Third Country Agreement is back in Federal Court. The U.S. is not safe for refugee claimants facing mass detention and deportation under intensified border crackdowns. Canada must uphold Charter equality rights and suspend the agreement.
— Canadian Council for Refugees (@ccrweb) November 12, 2026
Under the bilateral pact, which first took effect in December 2004 and was expanded across the entire 5,525-mile land border in 2024, migrants who present themselves at official ports of entry—or cross irregularly between crossings—are turned back to the country they first arrived in, under the legal fiction that both nations are equally safe havens for asylum seekers.
