Latest
In The News

Human Rights Groups Sue Canadian Government Over Returning Asylum Seekers Amid Trump's ICE Crackdown

Constitutional hearings opened in Toronto as Amnesty International and refugee advocates argue aggressive U.S. deportations mean America can no longer be deemed a safe third country.

Read the story
In The News · Read the story
Newstro In The News section banner.
Newstro
Share this story

Advocates mount constitutional challenge arguing U.S. immigration enforcement violates Charter equality protections

Toronto, Canada — November 13, 2026, 7:15 a.m. EST.

A formidable coalition of human rights organizations and refugee advocates returned to the Federal Court of Canada this week, launching a high-stakes constitutional lawsuit challenging the federal government's policy of turning back asylum seekers to the United States under the Safe Third Country Agreement (STCA).

Led by Amnesty International Canada, the Canadian Council for Refugees (CCR), and the Canadian Council of Churches, alongside eight individual refugee claimants, the legal action contends that aggressive mass deportations, expanded Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) roundups, and punitive detention policies under President Donald Trump have made the United States fundamentally unsafe for vulnerable people seeking sanctuary.

"The premise of the Safe Third Country Agreement has always been that the United States offers a fair, humane, and protective alternative asylum system," Gauri Sreenivasan, co-executive director of the Canadian Council for Refugees, told reporters outside the Toronto courthouse. "That premise has completely dissolved. Sending desperate individuals directly into the hands of an militarized ICE apparatus that detains them indefinitely and strips away due process is an abdication of Canada's legal and moral duties."

Under the bilateral pact, which first took effect in December 2004 and was expanded across the entire 5,525-mile land border in 2024, migrants who present themselves at official ports of entry—or cross irregularly between crossings—are turned back to the country they first arrived in, under the legal fiction that both nations are equally safe havens for asylum seekers.

The Section 15 equality claim: Why advocates argue turning back women and LGBTQ+ claimants is discriminatory

The new legal battle hinges on a pivotal constitutional issue left unresolved by Canada's highest court. In June 2023, the Supreme Court of Canada upheld the agreement under Section 7 of the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms, which guarantees life, liberty, and security of the person. However, the high court declined to rule on the challenge under Section 15—the Charter's robust guarantee of equality rights and protection against discrimination—and remanded the case back to the Federal Court.

In court filings presented before Justice Rochester in Toronto, the applicants submitted hundreds of pages of sworn affidavits detailing how the U.S. asylum system disproportionately penalizes marginalized claimants. Women fleeing gender-based violence, survivors of domestic abuse, and 2SLGBTQI+ individuals face severe statutory hurdles in U.S. immigration courts that do not exist under Canadian refugee jurisprudence.

Lawyers for the refugee groups pointed out that the Trump administration's reinstated administrative restrictions have systematically gutted gender-based and gang-related persecution claims, resulting in near-automatic summary rejections and rapid deportation orders without substantive judicial review.

"When Canada turns back a woman fleeing honor violence or a queer person fleeing state persecution, Canadian border agents are knowingly sending them into a system where their claims will be summarily denied," said Justin Mohammed, human rights campaigner at Amnesty International Canada. "That differential, punitive outcome violates Section 15 of our Charter. Equality before the law cannot stop at the border line."

Trump administration's mass deportation orders and expanded ICE detention reshape cross-border asylum reality

The legal challenge arrives at an extraordinary geopolitical juncture. Following the November 2024 presidential election, the White House initiated sweeping immigration enforcement decrees, expanding the use of expedited removal, deputizing local police forces, and directing federal authorities to erect sprawling temporary holding facilities across northern border sectors.

Attorneys for the Canadian Department of Justice argued in court that the federal cabinet retains broad executive prerogative to conduct foreign affairs and manage border accords. Government counsel maintained that bilateral diplomatic mechanisms and administrative safety valves remain in place to exempt individuals facing genuine risk of torture or cruel punishment.

However, plaintiffs presented evidence showing that discretionary exemptions are granted to fewer than two percent of those turned back at Canadian border crossings. Once returned to U.S. Customs and Border Protection custody, claimants are routinely transferred to private detention facilities in rural Pennsylvania, upstate New York, or Vermont, where legal representation is scarce and bond hearings are severely restricted.

The lawsuit also highlights the rising risk of "chain refoulement"—the international law violation where a country expels an asylum seeker to a transit state that subsequently deports them back to the country of origin where they face torture, imprisonment, or death.

Oral arguments in the Federal Court are scheduled to conclude Friday afternoon, with Justice Rochester expected to reserve judgment before issuing a comprehensive written decision in early 2027.

Federal Court of Canada hearings location in Toronto, Ontario

The map below highlights the Federal Court of Canada registry and courtroom facilities at 180 Queen Street West in downtown Toronto, Ontario, where constitutional hearings on the Safe Third Country Agreement are underway.

Map data: © OpenStreetMap contributors, ODbL.

Evolution of the Canada-U.S. Safe Third Country Agreement legal battle

December 29, 2004: The Safe Third Country Agreement takes formal effect between Canada and the United States, applying to land border crossings.

July 2020: Federal Court Justice Ann Marie McDonald rules the STCA unconstitutional under Section 7 of the Canadian Charter, citing U.S. detention conditions.

April 2021: The Federal Court of Appeal overturns McDonald's ruling on procedural grounds, keeping the agreement in force pending Supreme Court review.

March 25, 2024: Canada and the U.S. expand the STCA to cover irregular crossings across the entire 5,525-mile land boundary.

June 16, 2023: The Supreme Court of Canada upholds the STCA under Section 7 but sends Section 15 equality claims back to the Federal Court.

November 9–13, 2026: Federal Court in Toronto conducts extensive oral arguments examining whether U.S. ICE enforcement violates Charter equality rights.