Latest
In The News

Alex Murdaugh Seeks to Toss Double-Murder Indictments, Alleging State Agent Lied to Grand Jury

Murdaugh's defense team filed a 33-page motion in South Carolina circuit court claiming lead SLED investigator David Owen gave false grand jury testimony about blood spatter and ballistics ahead of his retrial.

Read the story
In The News · Read the story
Newstro In The News section banner.
Newstro
Share this story

Bombshell 33-page motion: Alex Murdaugh moves to toss double-murder indictments ahead of retrial

Walterboro, South Carolina — November 13, 2026, 12:15 p.m. EST.

Attorneys representing convicted South Carolina legal scion Alex Murdaugh have filed an aggressive 33-page motion demanding that a circuit judge throw out the original double-murder and weapons indictments against him, alleging that the lead state police investigator gave demonstrably false and perjured testimony to the grand jury.

The motion, submitted late Thursday in Colleton County Circuit Court by veteran defense attorneys Richard "Dick" Harpootlian and James "Jim" Griffin, takes direct aim at State Law Enforcement Division (SLED) Senior Special Agent David Owen. Owen served as the principal case agent in the investigation into the June 7, 2021 shotgun and rifle slayings of Murdaugh's 52-year-old wife, Maggie, and 22-year-old son, Paul, at their rural Moselle hunting estate in Islandton.

The defense contends that the grand jury indictments returned on July 14, 2022—which formed the constitutional foundation of the entire prosecution—were poisoned by deceptive testimony regarding physical evidence.

"The State cannot secure an indictment through false representations to citizens sworn to uphold the law, and then shrug off constitutional violations when exposed," Murdaugh's lawyers wrote in the filing before Circuit Judge Debra McCaslin. "Without Agent Owen's false statements, the grand jury had no physical evidence connecting Alex Murdaugh to the killings."

The aggressive legal move arrives at a critical juncture in the saga. Murdaugh’s March 2023 conviction and consecutive life sentences were vacated earlier this year by the South Carolina Supreme Court after an evidentiary inquiry confirmed improper communications and jury tampering by former Colleton County Clerk of Court Becky Hill. With prosecutors preparing to retry Murdaugh, the defense is attempting to prevent the case from reaching a jury altogether.

Blood spatter and ballistics: The contested SLED grand jury testimony

At the center of the defense motion is Agent Owen's sworn presentation to the Colleton County grand jury in July 2022 regarding the white cotton T-shirt Murdaugh wore on the night his wife and son were killed.

According to grand jury transcripts unsealed and cited in the motion, Owen testified that forensic testing had identified microscopic high-velocity impact blood spatter on the front of Murdaugh's shirt—critical physical proof indicating Murdaugh was standing in close proximity to Paul when the fatal 12-gauge shotgun blast was fired.

However, defense records reveal that SLED’s own forensic laboratory had completed comprehensive chemical and serological testing on the T-shirt nearly an entire year earlier, in July 2021. That definitive internal report explicitly concluded that no human blood was detected on the garment. Despite holding that exculpatory finding in his case file, Owen told grand jurors the opposite.

During Murdaugh's 2023 trial, Owen admitted under cross-examination that his grand jury statement about the blood spatter was inaccurate, attributing the statement to an honest misunderstanding of preliminary tests conducted by a private forensic consultant. But Harpootlian and Griffin argue that presenting disproven forensic claims to secure a capital indictment constitutes structural misconduct that cannot be cured after the fact.

The filing also accuses Owen of misrepresenting ballistic evidence, specifically claiming that unique extractor marks on spent shells at the crime scene matched shells found around the Moselle family residence, when ballistic examiners had reached only inconclusive determinations.

The State's counter-argument: Independent probable cause and kennel video timeline

South Carolina Attorney General Alan Wilson’s prosecution team fired back on Friday, maintaining that the murder charges will not be derailed and that Owen acted without malice.

Prosecutors argued that grand jury proceedings are protected by broad legal precedent, and that an isolated witness misstatement does not warrant dismissing an indictment when abundant independent probable cause exists to justify trial.

"A single mistaken statement by an investigator does not equate to bad faith or prosecutorial misconduct," state attorneys responded. "The grand jury was presented with an overwhelming mosaic of circumstantial and digital evidence establishing probable cause."

Chief among that evidence was the infamous kennel video recorded on Paul Murdaugh’s iPhone at 8:44 p.m. on the night of the murders—just minutes before Maggie and Paul ceased using their phones. While Murdaugh repeatedly told SLED investigators that he was never at the dog kennels that evening, multiple family friends and witnesses identified his distinctive southern drawl in the background of the recording.

Legal analysts note that even if Judge McCaslin were to dismiss the 2022 indictments, prosecutors could easily present the case to a new grand jury and secure fresh murder indictments within days, as Murdaugh remains behind bars serving separate lengthy prison sentences for federal financial fraud and embezzlement.

Colleton County Courthouse in Walterboro, South Carolina

The map below shows the historic Colleton County Courthouse in Walterboro, South Carolina, where the Murdaugh murder proceedings and defense filings are centered.

Map data: © OpenStreetMap contributors, ODbL.

Timeline of the Alex Murdaugh double-murder prosecution

June 7, 2021: Maggie and Paul Murdaugh are found shot to death near the dog kennels at Moselle in Colleton County.

July 2021: SLED laboratory testing concludes no human blood was detected on Murdaugh's white T-shirt.

July 14, 2022: Grand jury returns double-murder indictments following testimony by SLED Agent David Owen.

March 2, 2023: Following a six-week trial, Murdaugh is convicted of both murders and sentenced to two consecutive life terms.

September 2023: Defense files motion for new trial alleging jury tampering by court clerk Becky Hill.

Early 2026: South Carolina Supreme Court overturns convictions; case remanded for new trial.

November 13, 2026: Defense files 33-page motion seeking full dismissal of murder indictments over grand jury testimony.